国际教育网

繁体

学生项目|走进口述史:我们一起,来建一座普通人的博物馆

2023-10-12发布于广东

关注

滑动查看英文版本 Swipe for English version

 

我们一起,来建一座普通人的博物馆 

|走进口述史





关于

IDOH

全称为螺丝钉的岁月:东莞女工口述史,是由清澜山学校的高中生自发组织针对广东省东莞市女性工人的口述史采集项目,旨在通过与女工的深度访谈,以文字和影像的方式记录、传播她们的个人生活、从业经历、社会境遇。我们希望促进社会走进现代工业洪流中的个体命运,形成更深度、多元的人和人之间的联结。

在这一篇文章中,我们将以东莞女工口述史项目为案例,详列开展口述史访谈的步骤,并在最后分享一些我们可以将口述史融入日常生活的场景。



01

口述历史的通用准则&契约

由于口述史研究涉及到大量受访人的个人信息记录与传播,在开展口述访谈之前,请研究者务必确保受访人能够知情和同意采访人有关历史、社会和人性等多方面知识信息探索工作,并以其意愿为第一位选择访谈主题。

另外,口述史研究者也需对其出版作品的读者负起责任。在编篡的过程中需遵循以下原则:


1. 任何标注为口述历史的文字作品都必须有按照录音逐字逐句整理成文字的原始抄本为依据


2. 在不影响语义理解的前提下,尽可能保持受访人说话的言语特点,以折射出其背后的心理特性。若原始抄本中采访人提问的语句成分缺漏导致语意不全,或受访人答非所问,编篡人有权力和义务增补齐全,或改变问句形式,但所有的增补修订,都必须以恰当方式予以说明,例如恰当使用括号、异体字、注释、编辑说明等。

3. 根据不同分册的篇幅限制,编篡人可以对访谈内容进行必要的删减,但在删减时必须有共同的优先排序即“议程设置“,如从业史第一,社会经历史第二,个人生活史第三,个人心灵史第四,其他信息第五,口述历史言语特点第六。



02

口述历史的基本程序

01

选择对象及准备工作并开始联络

口述历史的选择对象标准是对项目感兴趣,且是访谈话题的关键人物(如历史事件的亲历者)。在项目时间资金有限的情况下,具有代表性、健谈的受访人优先。



口述历史工作首次联络所造成的第一印象会影响到受访人的合作意愿、态度、情绪乃至合作方式。一般正式联络的方式有三种:一是让熟人引荐,他们事先征得受访人同意,采访人再进一步联络;而是请已经完成采访的受访人引荐;三是直接联络,前提是对方认识并了解受访人。这三种联络方式相比较,受访人的引荐最好,请人引荐效果次之。因为受访人的推荐能够介绍口述历史采访的事由、意义和过程,更具说服力。

02

定期预访

策略:

相处模式在公众距离与私人距离的边界线附近


目的:

对受访人的个性特征及心灵状况进行现场了解和测评


口述历史受访者个性测评模式

1. 职业身份

2. 受教育程度及受教方式

3. 自尊与自信程度

4. 精神生活状态

5. 身体健康状态

6. 社交倾向

7. 直觉方式与经验类型

8. 情感类型及情绪稳定性

9. 智力水准

10. 心理开放程度及协同相容性

11. 思考与对话能力

12. 记忆方式及水准

13. 语言表述方式与能力、自我认知及运作自我类型

-让受访人了解采访人,获得信任与认同


-交流采访人的法律权利及采访人的道德义务、交流合作方式及工作期待与要求


-详细了解受访的生活经历以及其工作事业的历史,记录一些线索并提出一些问题

03

写作访问提纲征求意见稿并与对方及时交流

特殊问题:专门针对具体采访对象的专业经历及实际生平提出的,是由预访所得信息、有关文献资料信息、对受访人的个性心理测评综合而成


普通问题:针对所有采访对象的问题模型(可参考李镇《口述历史常规提问200问》)


提纲应保持半公文半私信形式,问候受访人,并对其毕生工作的重要意义进行简要评价,说明其个人口述的不可替代的历史价值


提纲应包含声明,尊重受访人,对工作方法和程序进行沟通探索


提问模式要根据预访中对受访人的了解和测评,不能随意照抄模型问题,以防出现刺激性的问题会无意间挫伤受访人的自尊或热情,甚至引发其心灵伤痛。

04

正式采访(录像,录音)

-受访人转成陈述者,是口述历史的主角;而采访人则要转成倾听者、提示者、会话人,即口述历史的配角。


-一般情况下,不宜打断叙述,除非我们确知叙述者的思维和记忆失去条理,才可做适当、温和而尽可能不露痕迹的提示,将话题引导焦点上来。


-一个好的口述历史,不论计划的目标是什么,总是会预留空间让受访者说出心里的话,而不是想办法把受访者的问答挤进预设的问题和思考模式里。


-采访者从态度和声调均要注意适度,尤需抑制乃至彻底消解强势企图或权威姿态。


-录像设备避免放在受访者直视范围内,否则可能影响受访人表现,与其自然状态有出入。


05

采访总结

-采访时间、地点、频率、时间长度、作者姓名、对受访人介绍评估(身体、心理、记忆力、表述方式)、对采访工作的思考总结。


-要有会话提要,与采访提纲两相比较,反应口述历史工作动态变化的全面情形




03

作为普通人,

我们可以如何一起做口述史?

- 每年清明节,一家人一起观看家中去世老人的录像,一同追忆缅怀老人的音容笑貌,对家中小辈讲述老人身前的故事,让后代得以了解家庭从哪里来



-父母在孩子每年生日时为他录一段像,回顾每年的成长收获和对未来的目标和憧憬。待到孩子长大,将录像作为礼物送给他,并与他一起观看。

- 子女在看望分居两地的父母时为他们录一段像,请他们分享自己的人生经历,在陪伴,倾听父母的同时让他们的思想和经验得以留存

- 学徒请手艺老师傅分享他们的从业经验以及工匠技艺,对其进行总结归纳,并在社会上传播,让大众走进传统工艺,看到匠人的执着和用心




参考文献

陈墨 《口述历史门径实务手册》


撰文 | 王玉琢

翻译|方子尧,赖玥颐

审校 | 曲孟雅老师, 神绮滢老师

排版 | 赖玥颐

图片 | 黄泽伟 & 部分来源网络,侵删 


                                                                    

                           

                      

Let's Build a Museum For Ordinary People Together|Exploring Oral History




About

IDOH

Our full name is Industrial Dongguan: An Oral Herstory. Initiated by Tsingaln high school students, this project aims to conduct in-depth interviews with female migrant workers in Dongguan, record and disseminate their personal stories. We hope to promote the society’s understanding of how the fate of individuals contributes to the modern industrial world, thus forming a deeper, more inclusive connection among people.

In this article, we will use IDOH Project as a case study example to outline the steps of conducting oral history interviews and, in the end, share some scenarios where we can integrate oral history into our daily lives. 



01

The General Guidelines and 

Covenants of Oral History

Because oral history research involves recording and disseminating a significant amount of personal information from interviewees, before conducting oral interviews, researchers must ensure that the interviewee is able to give informed consent to the interviewer’s exploration of different historical, social and human aspects of the topic.

Additionally, oral history researchers also have a responsibility to their readers when it comes to their published works. During the editing process, it is necessary to adhere to the following principles:


1. Any written work labeled as oral history must be based on real interviews. Oral history works must be based on the original transcripts, compiled word by word from the recordings.


2. The interviewee’s speech must be kept as specific as possible to reflect the emotional changes behind the interview, without affecting the semantic understanding. If the interviewer’s questions are missing from the original transcripts, resulting in incomplete meaning, or if the interviewee's answers are inaccurate, the editor has the right and obligation to add them all, or to change the form of the questions, but all additions and revisions must be explained in designated ways, such as parentheses, variant characters, comments, editorial notes, etc. 


3. Depending on the space limitations of the different sub-volumes, editors may make necessary deletions to the interviews, but these deletions must be made with a common priority ranking, such as professional experience first, socio-economic experience second, personal life history third, personal emotional history fourth, other information fifth, and oral history characteristics sixth.



02

The Fundamental Process of Oral History

01

1. Selecting interviewees and preparation work, 

then initiating contact

The criteria for selecting subjects for oral history are that they have an interest in the project and are key figures in the interview topics (such as eyewitnesses to historical events). For a project that is under limited funds and time, priority should be given to interviewees who are representative and talkative.


The first impression created by the initial contact in oral history can significantly impact the interviewee’s willingness to cooperate, their attitudes, emotions, and even the manner of cooperation. There are generally three formal methods of contact: First is to have acquaintances introduce the interviewer to the interviewee after obtaining the interviewee's consent in advance. Second, ask interviewees who have already been interviewed to refer the interviews to others. Third, direct contact: only when the interviewer knows and is familiar with the interviewee. Among these three methods of contact, being referred by the interviewee is the most effective, followed by being referred by someone else. This is because a referral by the interviewee can introduce the purpose, significance, and process of oral history interviews, making it more convincing.


02

Regular Pr-interview Visits

Strategy:

Interact in a mode that lies on the boundary between public distance and personal distance.


Purpose:

Gain on-site understanding and assessment of the interviewee's personality traits and mental state.


Personality Assessment Model for Oral History Interviewees:

1. Occupation

2. Level of education and educational background

3. Self-esteem and self-confidence

4. Mental state

5. Physical Health

6. Social Inclinations

7. Intuitive modalities and types of experiences

8. Emotional types and emotional stability

9. Intelligence Level

10. Psychological Openness and compatibility in cooperation

11. Thinking and Communication Abilities

12. Memory methods and proficiency

13. Verbal expression ability, self-awareness, and self-operating types

-Enables the interviewee to understand the interviewer and gain trust and acceptance


-Communicate the legal rights of the interviewer and the ethical obligations of the interviewer, discuss the collaboration methods, work expectations, and requirements


-Gain a comprehensive understanding of the interviewer’s life experiences, and history of their career, record relevant details and pose questions.


03

Drafting interview guidelines, seeking 

feedback and communicating promptly 

with the interviewee

Special QuestionsThese are specifically tailored to the interviewee's life experience. They are formulated by synthesizing information obtained during pre-interview research, relevant literature, and the interviewee's personality assessment.


General QuestionsThese are question models designed for all interviewees (referring to Li Zhen's "200 Standard Questions for Oral History").


The guidelines should maintain a semi-official, semi-personal format. They should begin with greetings to the interviewee and provide a brief evaluation of the significance of their lifelong work, emphasizing the irreplaceable historical value of their personal account.


The guidelines should include statements that respect the interviewee and discuss the methodology and procedures for the interview.


The questioning approach should be based on the understanding and assessment of the interviewee gained from the pre-interview. It should not be copy model questions to prevent inadvertently hurting the interviewee's self-esteem, and enthusiasm, or even triggering emotional distress.


04

Formal Interview(Video, Audio Recording)

- The interviewee becomes the narrator, the central figure in oral history, while the interviewer should transform into a listener, prompter, and conversational partner, serving as a supporting role in the oral history process.


-In general, it is not advisable to interrupt the narrative unless we are certain that the narrator's thoughts and memories are becoming disorganized. In such cases, it is appropriate to provide gentle and discreet prompts to bring the focus back to the topic.


-A good oral history interview, regardless of its goals, always allows space for the interviewee to express their thoughts and feelings, rather than trying to fit their responses into pre-set questions and thought patterns.


-Interviewers should be mindful of their attitude and tone, and it’s extremely important to restrain, and avoid displaying attempts at dominance or an authoritative posture.


-Video recording equipment should be placed outside the interviewee's direct sight to prevent it from potentially affecting the interviewee's performance and causing a departure from their natural state.


05

Interview Conclusion

-Includes information on interview time, location, frequency, duration, interviewer's name, assessment of the interviewee (physical, psychological, memory, verbal expression), and reflections on the interview process.


-There should be a summary of the conversation, comparing it with the interview guidelines, to reflect the comprehensive dynamics and changes in the oral history work.



03

How Can We, As Ordinary People, 

Conduct Oral History Together? 

-Every year during Qingming Festival, families gather to watch videos of passed-away elders, recalling and cherishing their memories, and sharing stories about the elders with the younger generations, helping them understand the family's origins.


-Parents record their child on his/her birthday each year, reflecting on the child's growth and achievements over the year, as well as their future goals and dreams. When the child grows up, the parents can present these videos as a gift and watch them together.


-Children who live separately from their parents can record video when visiting them, and ask them to share their life experiences. So that their thoughts and experiences can be retained while accompanying and listening to their parents.

- Apprentices can ask their skilled mentors to share their career experiences and craftsmanship. They can then summarize and disseminate this knowledge in society, allowing the public to walk into traditional crafts and see the dedication and craftsmanship of artisans.




声明:本文内容为国际教育号作者发布,不代表国际教育网的观点和立场,本平台仅提供信息存储服务。

免费联系清澜山学校TsinglanSchool

每天限50个名额

联系学校

提交成功后可以直接一键联系学校哦!

清澜山学校

课程设置:AP课程,美国课程,双语国际课程

学费区间:19-26万

快速匹配适合您孩子的学校

全国500所国际学校大全 / 3分钟匹配5-8所 / 1年名校升学备考托管服务

立即匹配

家长关注

为你推荐

预约看校

提交